In 2014, the U.S. National Airspace System (NAS) managed the progress of nearly 10 million flights. During peaks of airspace operations, there are thousands of commercial aircraft in flight, many concentrated over key metropolitan areas. With such high air traffic demand, airspace operations are not always the most efficient or coordinated, often due to the persistence of operating procedures that have largely remained unchanged from the earliest days of commercial aviation. As a result, the air transportation system often experiences unnecessary delays and lost productivity, and produces greater amounts of noise pollution, carbon dioxide, and other greenhouse gas emissions than if operations were more efficient. As air traffic demand is projected to grow over the next two decades, our current air traffic control system will be further strained and the environment adversely affected.
Improving the efficiency of the terminal area, which is the volume of airspace surrounding airports to a radius of about 50 miles, is an especially complex task due to operating characteristics that are quite distinct from the en route environment. Terminal area controllers manage both ascending and descending aircraft, more frequent turns, a wider range of separation standards, as well as terrain and increased traffic density within shorter time horizons.
In today's terminal area arrival operations, as an aircraft transitions for landing, controllers track and guide the aircraft from cruise altitude to the runway using simple visual aids as well as their skills and judgment. They issue turn-by-turn instructions (a process known as vectoring) via radio communications. As aircraft approach the runways from different directions, controllers manually merge aircraft and sequence them for arrival. Busy terminal area conditions often force the aircraft to fly inefficient arrival paths involving frequent changes in direction, altitude, and speed to maintain safe separation from other aircraft. Frequently, controllers must employ longer routes (known as path stretching) or holding patterns to tactically accommodate larger amounts of delay. The tactical nature of this manual approach leads to increased fuel burn and noise pollution, contributes to high controller workload, and exacerbates traffic congestion. Moreover, the imprecision of this current system creates greater uncertainty, and forces controllers to add buffers to the separation required between aircraft, which decreases airspace capacity, leading to further delays.
While more efficient arrival paths are achievable today, current technology limits their feasibility to periods of light traffic conditions, such as during the middle of the night. During periods of high-density traffic, maintaining safe separation and throughput takes precedence over achieving efficient operations. The technical challenge facing the aviation community is to make efficient arrival procedures common practice during heavy traffic when they are needed most, while still ensuring safety and throughput.
ATD-1 is the integration of three NASA technologies that provide a coordinated solution for managing arrival aircraft from just prior to their top-of-descent and continuing down to the runway.
NASA is collaborating with the FAA and industry partners to develop several advanced automation tools that provide air traffic controllers, pilots, and other airspace users with more accurate real-time information about the nation’s traffic flow, weather, and routing. The greater precision of this information is a key enabler of the Next Generation Air Transportation System (referred to as NextGen). NextGen is a comprehensive transformation of the NAS, which will be safer, more reliable and more efficient, and will reduce the impact of aviation on the environment. The transition to NextGen is vital to improving system performance, meeting continued growth in air traffic, and increasing the nation’s mobility to support economic progress.
NASA is developing an integrated set of NextGen technologies, called ATM Technology Demonstration-1 (ATD-1), that provides an efficient solution for managing arrival aircraft beginning from just prior to top-of-descent and continuing down to the runway. The ATD-1 suite of technologies has been tested separately, and each has demonstrated benefits in throughput, delay, and fuel-efficiency. Together, the technologies demonstrate the feasibility of high throughput of efficient arrival operations during peak traffic conditions in the terminal area. Simply put, the integration of these terminal arrival tools will allow arrival aircraft to safely fly closer together on more fuel-efficient routes to increase capacity, and reduce delay, fuel burn, noise, and greenhouse gas emissions. Moreover, with ATD-1 technologies, both pilots and controllers will have more accurate and timely information and advisories, thus reducing the need for extensive coordination and negotiation between them to achieve more efficient operations and alleviate controller workload.
The higher precision achieved by ATD-1 technologies will reduce the size of excess spacing buffers, resulting in higher terminal throughput and capacity.
Instead of tactically absorbing delay close to the airport, where it is traditionally handled using path stretching and holding patterns, subtle variations in speed are applied from cruise altitude to landing to distribute small amounts of delay still required over a longer portion of the flight. Strategically absorbing delay in this way relieves congestion that would otherwise build up near the airport, further increasing the efficiency of terminal area traffic flows. The more orderly, precise, and direct traffic flow enabled by the ATD-1 technologies will make the NAS more predictable overall. This allows airspace users to better respond to unexpected delays caused by convective weather and other airspace constraints.
The ATD-1 technologies include:
Time-Based Flow Management (TBFM)
Controller Managed Spacing (CMS)
Flight Deck Interval Management (FIM)
Time-Based Flow Management (TBFM) generates a conflict-free arrival schedule based on airport conditions, airport capacity, required spacing, and weather conditions. The schedule increases use of the FAA's Performance-Based Navigation (PBN) arrival procedures, which use more direct routes that extend from en route airspace and continue through terminal airspace to the runway. Arrival scheduling involves metering of traffic flows in the terminal area to ensure that aircraft merge smoothly from different directions and avoid downstream congestion that would otherwise prevent them from flying efficient flight paths. The schedule is determined well in advance of execution and it is communicated to controllers at both Air Route Traffic Control Centers (ARTCC) and Terminal Radar Control (TRACON) facilities. Flight crews know their intended flight path, which aircraft they ought to be following, and the desired spacing interval at critical points along their designated PBN route to reach the destination airport safely and on schedule. Controllers no longer have to make as many tactical interventions concerning merges and arrival slots, with short time horizons, relative to today's operations.
Time-Based Flow Management (TBFM) determines an arrival schedule that increases use of more direct arrival routes for safe, orderly, and expeditious flow of traffic in the terminal area.
Controller Managed Spacing (CMS) decision support tools provide controllers with the information needed to precisely space aircraft at merge points using speed adjustments instead of vectoring. CMS enhances the controller's current display with textual and graphical representations of the terminal arrival schedule created by TBFM to indicate where an aircraft is expected to be along its PBN route, and calculates the speed advisories needed to maintain this schedule. Thus, controllers have advisories to help prevent congestion near the runway and continue use of PBN procedures during heavy traffic conditions.
Controller Managed Spacing (CMS) tools provide controllers with the information needed to precisely space all aircraft to meet terminal metering schedules.
ATD-1 also has advisory tools targeted for the pilots. It is anticipated that some aircraft will have sophisticated onboard avionics that enable pilots to maintain their own spacing to achieve the TBFM schedule. In lieu of speed instructions from controllers, the Flight Deck Interval Management (FIM) capability provides speed guidance to pilots to precisely maintain an aircraft’s spacing behind another aircraft. These speed advisories use information provided by Automatic Dependent Surveillance - Broadcast (ADS-B) technology aboard the aircraft that is more accurate than traditional radar. Flight crews are able to make finer adjustments to their speed and react more quickly to achieve the necessary spacing. With further TBFM support, the tighter control enabled by FIM is expected to reduce excess spacing between aircraft, resulting in higher airport throughput.
Flight Deck Interval Management (FIM) tools aboard the aircraft enable flight crews to precisely space their aircraft relative to others to achieve ideal spacing.
The ATD-1 system has been evaluated in a series of high-fidelity human-in-the-loop simulations to mature the technologies towards operational use.
The FAA refers to ATD-1's ground automation tools (i.e., TBFM and CMS) as Terminal Sequencing and Spacing, or TSAS. From 2009-2015, twenty-five high-fidelity human-in-the-loop simulations were conducted by NASA to mature TSAS from proof-of-concept design to a demonstration prototype. Arrival procedures at several airports in the United States were simulated (using active and retired controllers with extensive operational knowledge) to gain experience with a broad range of traffic demand scenarios and wind conditions. NASA and the FAA also conducted an operational integration assessment of TSAS with current FAA NextGen hardware and software to reduce the risk in operational implementation.
The simulations initially focused on the integration of the various TSAS components, and were followed by simulations to refine the TSAS concept of operations in response to controller feedback. The final simulations evaluated the performance, controller acceptability, and operational integration of a demonstration TSAS prototype. Results from simulation testing of TSAS were favorable, overall demonstrating markedly increased PBN utilization by controllers and modestly improved spacing accuracy without increased workload.
Demonstration prototypes of the TSAS tools were transferred to the FAA in 2014 for further testing and evaluation, and the final technology transfer package is planned for December 2015. TSAS is targeted for deployment to several busy airports in the United States beginning in 2019. NASA will continue providing technical support throughout the remaining phases of deployment.
ATD-1's airborne and ground automation for FIM is also referred to by the FAA as Interval Management - Arrivals, Approaches and Cruise (IM AAC), which is the first instantiation of IM based on arrival, approach and cruise operations to independent runways in an environment preceding data communication. NASA has tested the FIM capability in eleven laboratory simulations of increasing capability and maturity, leading to a flight demonstration on board the Boeing 787 EcoDemonstrator in December 2014. The flight demonstration served as a proof-of-concept flight test to assess the risks associated with FIM flight operations involving two or more coordinated aircraft. The latest version of the FIM algorithm, known as Airborne Spacing for Terminal Arrival Routes (ASTAR), supports RTCA-based industry standards for the FIM system and it is being used as the basis for avionics prototyping efforts to build, test, and fly the ATD-1 FIM system.
NASA is collaborating with industry partners to develop prototype flight hardware and software based on ASTAR, and install the system on two test aircraft for further evaluation in a flight test planned for early 2017. NASA plans to transfer the prototype FIM system and all associated products to the FAA for further testing by 2018.
Benefits of ATD-1's Integrated Terminal Area Scheduling Technologies
Operational Integration Assessment (OIA) of NASA's Terminal Sequencing and Spacing (TSS) Completed
May 28, 2015
The Operational Integration Assessment (OIA) was a joint FAA/NASA operational assessment of the FAA's Ground-based Interval Management for Spacing (GIM-S) integrated with NASA's Terminal Sequencing and Spacing (TSS) ground automation technology in an operational-like environment at the FAA's William J. Hughes Technical Center (WJHTC). + Learn more
FAA Approves Deployment of NASA's Terminal Sequencing and Spacing (TSS)
May 1, 2015
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) successfully passed its final investment decision for full-scale implementation of the latest NASA-developed air traffic management (ATM) tools that allow air traffic controllers to maximize the benefits of Performance Based Navigation (PBN) procedures on approach to the runway. + Learn more
Completion of Operational Integration Assessment (OIA) Shakedown #2
May 1, 2015
The Operational Integration Assessment (OIA) is an FAA/NASA demonstration of the FAA's Ground-based Interval Management for Spacing (GIM-S) integrated with NASA's Terminal Sequencing and Spacing (TSS) ground automation technology. The second OIA shakedown was completed April 28-30, 2015. + Learn more
FIAT-5 Data Collection Completed
December 12, 2014
Twenty participants, comprised of eleven pseudo-pilots and nine controller subjects, took part in the second and last human-in-the-loop (HITL) simulation and data collection for the Fully-Integrated ATD-1 Test (FIAT)-5 during December 2-9th, 2014. + Learn More
FIAT-5 Shakedown Completed
October 3, 2014
The Fully-Integrated ATD-1 Test (FIAT) simulation #5 shakedown was conducted the week of September 29-October 3, 2014 and met all simulation objectives. + Learn More
Shakedown Simulation for Fully-Integrated ATD-1 Test (FIAT) #5 Completed
September 19, 2014
About 20 subjects participated in a series of shakedown runs of the Fully-Integrated ATD-1 Test (FIAT) #5 experiment, over three days during the week of September 8. + Learn More
Method to Enhance Scheduled Arrival Robustness (MESAR) Pilot Training and Data Collection Completed
September 19, 2014
The Method to Enhance Scheduled Arrival Robustness (MESAR) team completed two weeks of pseudo-pilot training with Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) and data collection with two different groups of participants from August 11-29. + Learn More
Tackling Optimized Profile Descent Procedures
September 8, 2014
Article by John Croft Washington. A version of this article appears in the September 8 issue of Aviation Week & Space Technology (page 36). + Read the article
Operational Integration Assessment (OIA) Progress Continues
September 4, 2014
Successful initial integration of the Terminal Sequencing and Spacing (TSS)-enhanced Standard Terminal Automation Replacement System (STARS) prototype into the FAA's William J. Hughes Technical Center (WJHTC) lab was achieved in August. + Learn More
NASA and FAA Operational Integration Assessment for Terminal Sequencing and Spacing Kickoff Meeting
August 22, 2014
NASA and the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) are planning an Operational Integration Assessment (OIA) of the Terminal Sequencing and Spacing (TSS) technology. + Learn More
Fully-Integrated ATD-1 Test (FIAT) Shakedown Simulation #5 Completed
August 8, 2014
The second shakedown simulation of FIAT-5 was conducted from July 28-31 and focused on Albuquerque Center (ZAB) airspace. + Learn More
NASA Turns Over Next-Generation Air Traffic Management Tool to FAA
July 15, 2014
NASA press release on the technology transfer of the Terminal Sequencing and Spacing technologies from NASA to the FAA. + Learn More
Delivery of STARS Version of ATD-1 Ground Tool Software
May 29, 2014
On May 22, 2014, NASA accepted the Raytheon delivery and demonstration of the "SCOUT" version of the Air traffic management Technology Demonstration-1 (ATD-1) ground tools software. + Learn More
Fully Integrated ATD-1 Test (FIAT) 4 Completes Shakedown Simulations
November 1, 2013
Human-in-the-loop simulations were completed the week of October 28 to evaluate the performance of the ATD-1 system, specifically assessing the new airborne spacing algorithm (ASTAR12) in a variety of wind conditions and traffic scenarios. + Learn More
Terminal Sequencing and Spacing-2 (TSS-2) Simulation
April 18, 2012
In April 2013, the Division hosted the successful completion of a two-week, high-fidelity Air Traffic Control (ATC) simulation of the Air traffic management Technology Demonstration-1 (ATD-1) technologies, focusing on the ATD-1 ground scheduling and control tool which the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has adopted, and is calling Terminal Sequencing and Spacing (TSS). + Learn More
Air Traffic Management Technology Demonstration-1 (ATD-1) Research Transition Team Kickoff
November 15, 2012
The ATD-1 team participated in a kickoff meeting of the NASA-FAA Research Transition Team on November 6-7 in Washington, DC. + Learn More
Fully Integrated ATD-1 Test (FIAT) Simulation Achieves Major Milestone
October 19, 2012
The Terminal Area Precision Scheduling and Spacing (TAPSS) research group has made major strides in the past four months, extending the TAPSS system to include the flight deck interval management capabilities for human-in-the-loop (HITL) evaluation. + Learn More
Validation of Air traffic management Technology Demonstration-1 (ATD-1) ground-based scheduling and controller advisory tools
October 19, 2012
From September 10-14, 2012, Aviation Systems Division researchers completed a simulation to validate the Federal Aviation Administration's (FAA's) interest in ATD-1 tools to enhance the FAA's current NextGen investment in Performance Based Navigation (PBN) procedures throughout the National Airspace System. + Learn More
Completion of ATD-1/STARS Feasibility Study
October 19, 2012
In September 2012, a Raytheon Corporation team under contract to NASA successfully completed a demonstration of an Air traffic management Technology Demonstration-1 (ATD-1) feasibility study that will significantly reduce the risk of technology transfer of the ATD-1 ground tools to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). + Learn More
ATD-1 highlights for fiscal year 2012 + Learn More
ATD-1 Tech Transfer Documents
Version 2, February 2014 + See List
"NASA's ATM Technology Demonstration-1: Moving NextGen Arrival Concepts from the Laboratory to the Operational NAS"
Swenson, H.N., Robinson, J.E., and Winter, S., Journal of Air Traffic Control, Summer 2013, Volume 55, No. 2, pp. 27-37. + Download PDF Version (Preprint)
"Air Traffic Management Technology Demonstration-1 Concept of Operations (ATD-1 ConOps)"
Baxley, B., Johnson, W.C., Swenson, H.N., Robinson, J.E., Prevot, T., Callantine, T.J., Scardina, J., Greene, M., NASA TM-2012-217585, July 2012. + Download PDF Version
"Air Traffic Management Technology Demonstration-1 Concept of Operations (ATD-1 ConOps), Version 2.0"
Baxley, B., Johnson, W.C., Swenson, H.N., Robinson, J.E., Prevot, T., Callantine, T.J., Scardina, J., Greene, M., NASA TM-2013-218040, Sep. 2013. + Download PDF Version
"NASA's ATM Technology Demonstration-1: Integrated Concept of Arrival Operations"
Baxley, B., Swenson, H., Prevot, T., Callantine, T., 31st Digital Avionics Systems Conference (DASC), Williamsburg, VA, 14-18 Oct. 2012. + Download PDF Version
"Design and Evaluation of the Terminal Area Precision Scheduling and Spacing System," Swenson, H.N., Thipphavong, J., Sadovsky, A., Chen, L., Sullivan, C., and Martin, L., 9th USA/Europe ATM R&D Seminar (ATM2011), Berlin, Germany, 14-17 June 2011. + Download PDF Version
"Efficiency Benefits Using the Terminal Area Precision Scheduling and Spacing System," Thipphavong, J., Swenson, H., Lin, P., Seo, A.Y., and Bagasol, L.N., AIAA-2011-6971, 11th American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) Aviation Technology, Integration, and Operations (ATIO) Conference, Virgina Beach, VA, 20-22 Sep. 2011. + Download PDF Version
"Effects of Scheduling and Spacing Tools on Controllers' Performance and Perceptions of Their Workload," Martin, L., Swenson, H., Sadovsky, A., Thipphavong, J., Chen, L., and Seo, A. Y., 30th Digital Avionics Systems Conference (DASC), Seattle, WA, 16-20 Oct. 2011. + Download PDF Version
"A Concept for Robust, High Density Terminal Air Traffic Operations," Isaacson, D. R., Robinson III, J. E., Swenson, H., and Denery, D.,10th AIAA Aviation Technology, Integration, and Operations (ATIO) Conference, Fort Worth, TX, 13-15 Sep. 2010. + Download PDF Version
2011 DASC Best in Session Award
“Effects of Scheduling and Spacing Tools on Controller's Performance and Perceptions of their Workload” authored by Lynne Martin (code TH), Harry Swenson, Alex Sadovsky, Jane Thipphavong, Liang Chen and Anthony Seo (all of code AF) was awarded best paper in session. The paper documented recent Terminal Area Precision Spacing and Scheduling (TAPSS) system human-in-the-loop simulation experiments and the positive system performance and workload benefits. + Download the file
2011 NASA Honor Award
The TAPSS Team received a Group Achievement Award “for groundbreaking research, development and real-time simulation of a state-of-the-art area scheduling system for NextGen terminal area air traffic operations.” The team included representatives from NASA Ames, Optimal Synthesis Inc., San Jose State University, and UC Santa Cruz/UARC. + More Info